Skip to content

Welcome to Alchemist's Refuge - Your source for Trading Card Games and Accessories!

Search

Menu

Magic
Preorder MTG: Marvel Super Heroes

High $$ Cards

Play @ The Refuge
Pokemon
Play Pokemon @ The Refuge

Graded Pokemon

Send your cards to PSA
Sports
Board Games
Other Games
Play Riftbound @ The Refuge

Shop Board Games

Play SWU @ The Refuge
Accessories
Die Hard Life Counters

Old School Gemstone Dice

The Academic Deck Box
Social
Help

Magic: the Gathering - Cards Over $5

(2445 products)

Sort by

Featured
Most relevant
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old

Compare

View as List Grid

FiltersFilter & Sort

Applied Filters

Clear all

Sort by

Featured
Most relevant
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old

Availability

In stock (2445)
Out of stock (116)

Clear

Game

Magic: The Gathering (1249)

Clear

Price

From $

-

To $

From To

Clear

Set Code

40K (1)
DRC (1)
ECL (17)
EOE (15)
FCA (10)
FIC (19)
FIN (48)
MAR (19)
MSC (25)
MSH (10)
SOA (17)
SOC (5)
SOS (18)
SPE (3)
SPM (22)
TDC (2)
TDM (23)
TLA (26)
TLE (19)
TMC (39)
TMT (28)

Clear

Grade

10 (2)

Clear

Rarity

Common (96)
COMMON (3)
Mythic (84)
MYTHIC (77)
Mythic Rare (298)
Rare (690)
RARE (51)
Uncommon (135)
UNCOMMON (5)

Clear

Finish

Foil (676)
Non-Foil (867)

Clear

Treatments

[Borderless] (77)
[Extended Art] (29)
[Serialized] (3)
[Showcase] (4)
Booster Fun (33)
Borderless (9)
Extended Art (14)
Full Art (51)
Japanshowcase (15)
Showcase (44)
Silverscroll (12)
Sourcematerial (7)
Standard (1)
Universes Beyond (147)

Clear

Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Forest (495) - [Galaxy Foil, Borderless] Unfinity (UNF)

$11.79 USD

Very low stock (1 unit)

View details
Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Forest - Unglued (UGL)

$10.99 USD

In stock (12 units)

View details
Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Forest - [Foil] Double Masters (2XM)

$6.79 USD

Very low stock (1 unit)

View details
Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Forest // Forest (25) - [Full Art] Jurassic World Collection (REX)

$8.79 USD

Very low stock (1 unit)

View details
Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Forge Anew - [Foil, Extended Art] The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth (LTR)

$8.39 USD

Very low stock (1 unit)

View details
Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Forge Anew - [Foil] The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth (LTR)

$6.59 USD

Very low stock (1 unit)

View details
Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Forge Anew - [Surge Foil, Extended Art] The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth (LTR)

$6.39 USD

Low stock (6 units)

View details
Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Forgotten Cave - [Foil, Retro Frame] Onslaught (ONS)

$11.39 USD

Very low stock (1 unit)

View details
Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Formidable Speaker (366) - [Extended Art] Lorwyn Eclipsed (ECL)

From $13.79 USD

Very low stock (2 units)

View details
Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Forsaken Monument - Commander Masters (CMM)

$6.39 USD

Very low stock (1 unit)

View details
Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Forsaken Monument - Modern Horizons 3 Commander (M3C)

$6.79 USD

Very low stock (1 unit)

View details
Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Forsaken Wastes - Mirage (MIR)

$16.39 USD

Very low stock (1 unit)

View details
Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Fractured Sanity - [Foil, Showcase] Modern Horizons 2 (MH2)

$6.39 USD

Very low stock (1 unit)

View details
Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Freed from the Real (425) - [Foil, Showcase] Secret Lair Drop (SLD)

$27.59 USD

Very low stock (1 unit)

View details
Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Frodo, Sauron's Bane - [Surge Foil, Showcase Scroll] The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth (LTR)

$10.39 USD

Very low stock (1 unit)

View details
Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Frontier Bivouac - [Surge Foil] Doctor Who (WHO)

$9.99 USD

Very low stock (1 unit)

View details
Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Fury Storm - Commander 2018 (C18)

$5.59 USD

Very low stock (2 units)

View details
Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Fyndhorn Elves - Ice Age (ICE)

$5.39 USD

Very low stock (1 unit)

View details
Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Fyndhorn Elves - [Extended Art] Commander Legends (CMR)

$7.99 USD

Very low stock (1 unit)

View details
Compare

Wizards of the Coast
Fyndhorn Elves - [Foil] Commander Legends (CMR)

$11.99 USD

Low stock (8 units)

View details

Previous
Page 41 / 123
1
…
39
40
41
42
43
…
123
Next

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Subtotal: $0.00 USD

Loading...

We're Located at:

11925 Montgomery Road
Suite 4
Cincinnati, OH 45249
(513) 445-4472

Hours

Monday: 12pm - 9pm
Tuesday: 12pm - 9pm
Wednesday: 12pm - 9pm
Thursday: 12pm - 9pm
Friday: 12pm - Midnight
Saturday: 12pm - Midnight
Sunday: 12pm - 9pm

Helpful Links

Login
Create An Account
Contact Us
Search
Order Policies

Newsletter

Sign up for exclusive offers, events and more.

Email

Payment methods accepted

Country/Region

United States (USD $)

Country/Region

© 2026 Alchemist's Refuge. Powered by Shopify.

Compare /3

Loading...

Loading...

Choose options

Item added to your cart.

View cart